Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

BasicTradingTips.comBasicTradingTips.com

Editor's Pick

Who Loses from Immigration Restrictions?

Jeffrey Miron

A long-standing concern about immigration is that it might reduce job opportunities for native workers:

In 1882, the US government passed the Chinese Exclusion Act, which banned laborers born in China from entering the United States and prevented individuals born in China already residing in the United States from obtaining citizenship or reentering the country.… Proponents argued that Chinese workers—who constituted 12 percent of the male working-age population and 21 percent of all immigrants in the Western United States—reduced economic opportunities for white workers.

Yet in 1882, similarly to now,

many business owners opposed the act. They worried that highly productive Chinese labor could not be easily replaced and that a sweeping ban would lead to significant economic losses.

So what were the act’s effects? According to recent research,

the act reduced the Chinese labor supply by 64 percent. A reduction occurred for both skilled and unskilled workers.

This is presumably what the act’s supporters intended. In addition, however,

the act reduced the white male labor supply by 28 percent and lowered this group’s lifetime earnings.

Further, and relevant to current debates,

the act reduced total manufacturing output by 62 percent and the number of manufacturing establishments by 54–69 percent.

What is the explanation? Reduced immigration means higher labor costs. This implies reduced output, and thus reduced demand for native labor, even if businesses partially substitute native for immigrant labor. Reduced immigration can therefore be “lose-lose,” hurting native workers and businesses, in addition to harming immigrants.

This article appeared on Substack on January 23, 2024.

You May Also Like

Tech News

Illustration by Samar Haddad / The Verge You may be wondering how to delete your Facebook account now that fact-checking is no longer considered...

Tech News

NBC Between Nosferatu and Wolf Man, it feels like Hollywood has come back around on good, old fashioned monster movies. And it seems like...

Tech News

The company created a sensation by making TVs that look more like art and less like tech. With The Frame Pro, Samsung is trying...

World News

Ireland is suffering from the same kind of housing crisis that has hurt the US. Not surprisingly, the crises in both countries have their...