Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Editor's Pick

FISA Bill of Rights Sellout Update

Patrick G. Eddington

turner

Rep. Mike Turner (R‑OH), chairman of the US House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence. (Getty Images)

The new version of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) Section VII “reform” bill was posted earlier this afternoon on the House Rules Committee website. Its backers will no doubt try to sell it as a genuine reform measure. In reality, it’s an example of the classic Capitol Hill game of “Let’s not, but say we did.”

To give you a sense of how successful the National Security State‐​friendly House Intelligence Committee has been in hijacking this debate, remember that it was less than two months ago that the House Judiciary Committee—which has always had primary jurisdiction over FISA since its enactment in 1978—passed an excellent and substantive FISA reform bill out of its committee by an incredible 35–2 bipartisan vote. That bill contains two incredibly important provisions: 1) a warrant requirement for FBI personnel if they want to access stored FISA Section 702 data on US Persons, and 2) language banning the purchase of information from data brokers by federal law enforcement, instead requiring a warrant to get that kind of data as well.

Neither provision is in the bill posted this afternoon by the House Rules Committee.

Also of note is that the new bill creates a special carveout for House and Senate members to be informed if the FBI conducts a FISA Section 702 database query that returns or might return information on the member of Congress:

Special notification provision for House-Senate members re: FISA queries

No other American gets that kind of special treatment under the bill.

The bill also allows completely undefined “national security investigations”:

Undefined "national security investigation" language in HPSCI FISA bill

I could go on, but you probably get the point by now.

So is it a done deal?

Tomorrow, the House Freedom Caucus is holding a press conference on this issue:

HFC FISA press conference announcement for 2/13/24

The announcement does not tip HFC’s hand on where its members stand. Will they encourage passage or oppose it? Will they threaten another motion to vacate the chair unless the House Judiciary bill is brought up instead?

How this small but incredibly powerful voting block comes down will decide whether or not real FISA reform will happen this Congress.

You May Also Like

Editor's Pick

One of the key themes, if not THE theme, of 2023 was the dominance of the mega-cap growth trade. The Magnificent 7 stocks handily outperformed...

Editor's Pick

Eric Gomez On January 25, Taiwan’s military inducted its first group of conscripts for a one‐​year service period since Taipei announced the extension of mandatory...

Editor's Pick

In this episode of StockCharts TV‘s The MEM Edge, Mary Ellen reviews where the markets stand as we head into earnings from MSFT, GOOGL, AAPL and...

Editor's Pick

The previous week was reduced to just a short 3-day trading week as Monday was declared a special holiday while on Friday, the markets...